Christmas Carol Voting Bracket 2

[dvdguy]

Which gets your vote?

[dvdguy]

i voted for george c scott here. I love Patrick Stewart but I had to give it to george

[dvdguy]

poll update:

Its a tie as of today 2/20/2008
Who is going to come out on top?

Poll closes 10/31/2008 with the winner going on to the final voting

[auntieclaus]

I agree Patrick Stewart is a close second!

[dvdguy]

there goes the tiecheesy

[sugarplum fairy]

I'm a cartoon fanatic, so I had to vote for The Flintstones.

[dvdguy]

I agree on the cartoons. I love them

[dvdguy]

poll update:

Its a tie as of today 3/20/2008
Who is going to come out on top?

Poll closes 10/31/2008 with the winner going on to the final voting

[pbrbullrider]

George C. Scott was my opion the best Scrooge ever.

Jeff G. "bullrider"

[DoubleA]

Like I said in the other thread Bah Hum Duck is a lot of fun to watch. Brings a little extra laughter to Christmas.

[dvdguy]

poll update:

George c scott in the lead as of today 4/21/2008

Poll closes 10/31/2008 with the winner going on to the final voting

[AuntieMistletoeDear]

cheesy There I go again. These are great polls, D-G ... not easy. It's hard for me to make a decision when there are several tempting choices (you should see me ordering dinner at a restaurant) - in the end I went with Mr. Magoo's Christmas Carol.
My mom played BlackJack with Jim Backus (a.k.a. Mr. Magoo and Thurston Howell the Third)

[dvdguy]

I hope she won

[AuntieMistletoeDear]

cheesy I believe she did.

That was the year people mistakenly held the door or moved out of her way and referred to her as "Liza" thinking she was Liza Manelli.

She almost signed an autograph, but my dad stopped her.

[dvdguy]

Aw he should have let her

[AuntieMistletoeDear]

:treeguy: I'm sure he was in a rush to get to a live performance otherwise he might have gone along with it.

[AuntieMistletoeDear]

:hello: Oh yeah, this brings me to another thought ... if anyone heard or read that Liza was eluding folks and being a tad rude by not stopping to speak with her fans in the mid-70's, relax - it was just my mom.

HaHa.

[dvdguy]

funny

[George Broderick, Jr.]

:rudolph:Mr Magoo was, in my opinion, the BEST version of A Christmas Carol... EVER! When he sings "I'm All Alone In The World" with young Magoo/Scrooge, it brings a tear to my eye every time!

Plus, I could never understand how The Flintstones, a PRE-historic family would even know about Christmas, since it would be thousands of years until the birth of Christ...

But, that's just me...

[dvdguy]

minor technicality

[AuntieMistletoeDear]

Now that you mention it George - A Muppet Christmas Carol and Mickey's Christmas Carol get those puddles filling up in the old eyeballs too, in the end it was Mr. Magoo who tugged the most for me in this round.

[George Broderick, Jr.]

:rudolph:And Magoo had those great songs, too! By Jules Stine and (IIRC) Bob Merrill... a Broadway writing team that treated Magoo as a legitimate job and not just another "kiddie cartoon"... did you know that the Barrbara Streisand classic "People" was originally written for Magoo's Christmas Carol..? For some reason or other, it never made the final cut... being replaced (I believe) with "Winter Was Warm" at the eleventh hour.

"We're rep-re-hensible... we'll steal your pen and pen-ci-ble"

It doesn't get any better than that!

[ksrjreed]

I voted for Mr. Magoo's Christmas Carol, I don't care what anyone says, Mr. Magoo is Scrooge.

[dvdguy]

poll update:

george c scott is on top as of today 5/22
poll update:

Poll closes 10/31/2008 with the winner going on to the final voting

[RavenHardt]

I like Kelsey's version and that is what I voted for....however, there has never been a bad version of a christmas carol.....period

[Mumof2]

Kids love the Flintstones. :)

[dvdguy]

poll update:

george c. scott is in the lead as of today 6/27/2008

Who will come out on top?!

Poll closes 10/31/2008 with the winner going on to the final voting

[Wenceslaus]

Where's the big screen musical SCROOGE (1970), starring Albert Finney? You passed that up, but included some Animaniacs episode?

Bah, humbug!

A clip: "Thank You Very Much" (http://youtube.com/watch?v=uiNMz_745vQ)

[AuntieMistletoeDear]

:hello: Albert Finney's version is in another poll - go to this one to cast your vote.


http://www.mymerrychristmas.com/forum/showthread.php?t=8282

cheesy Thanks for your comment.

[irishsnow]

A Christmas Carol (George C Scott)

[momnan30]

Which gets your vote?

Not for nothin' but where is Mickey's Christmas Carol?

[dvdguy]

I believe he is in the other group (http://www.mymerrychristmas.com/forum/showthread.php?t=8282)

[momnan30]

I believe he is in the other group (http://www.mymerrychristmas.com/forum/showthread.php?t=8282)
sorry, missed that one...whew!

[dvdguy]

No problem, theres also several other voting groups for other movies

[miller4plusmore]

I like Kelsey's version and that is what I voted for....however, there has never been a bad version of a christmas carol.....period


AGREE! It's my absolute favorite Christmas story!

:snowball:

[starflake]

Patrick Stewart all the way.

[dvdguy]

poll update:

george c scott is on top as of today 7/24
poll update:

Poll closes 10/31/2008 with the winner going on to the final voting

[dvdguy]

poll update as of today 8/20:

George C Scott's version is running away with the votes in this group.
Will he maintain his commanding lead all the way to the end?

Vote now, Let your voice be heard!cheesy